ALKENES II: REACTIONS OF ALKENES
TOP 
 
TABLE OF CONTENTS FOR THIS 
  PAGE
  - Reaction types 
  
 - Reaction Mechanisms 
  
 - Transition State Theory 
  
 - Reaction Path Diagrams 
  
 - Reaction Rates and Rate Constants 
  
 - An Example of a Reaction Mechanism 
    
  
 - Reaction Path Diagram For this Example 
    
  
 - Transition States 
  
 - Transition State Models 
  
 - Resonance Theory of Transition States 
    
  
 - Regiospecificity and Competing Transition 
    States 
  
 - Relative Rates of Addition to Different 
    Alkenes 
  
 - Stabilization of Carbocations by 
    Alkyl Groups 
  
 - Transition State Refinement: The Hammond 
    Postulate 
 
 
 
REACTION TYPES
 
 
  - Organic reactions are classified as to Reaction Type 
    based upon the overall changes which occur in the product as compared to the 
    reactant(s). 
 
  
  - For alkenes the distinctive reaction type is Addition. 
    
 
  
  - This is because the pi bond of an alkene can be broken and 
    this bond replaced by bonds to other (external) agents. For example, ethene 
    can add molecular hydrogen to give ethane. In this reaction, two reagents 
    add together to give a single product. This is typical of the type 
    of reactions that alkenes undergo. 
 
  
  - Alkenes are especially reactive because the pi 
    bond is relatively much weaker than a sigma bond.  
 
 
  - In contrast, alkanes cannot undero addition at all, 
    because the carbons of an alkane already have the maximum number of atoms 
    (four) bonded to them. They therefore cannot add another atom. For example 
    ethane can not add more hydrogen . Substitution, 
    where, for example, a hydrogen atom of an alkane is replaced by some other 
    atom or group, such as a halogen atom is the typical reaction. 
 
  
  - The symbol for an addition reaction is "Ad", 
    wherease that for a substitution is "S".  
 
 
REACTION MECHANISMS
 
 
 
  - A Reaction Mechanism is a stepwise description 
    of the reaction path. In our course this will consist of a set of chemical 
    equations along with certain other specifications (to be specified later) 
    such as the rate determining step. 
 
  
  - The term Reaction Path refers to the lowest 
    energy pathway from the reactants to the products, i.e., the one 
    which is actually preferred and followed in a chemical reaction. Many 
    paths are conceivable, but the easiest and fastest way to convert reactants 
    to products is via the lowest energy path. 
 
  
  - The importance of knowing the mechanism of a reaction lies 
    in the ability to (1)exert some control over the reaction in regard to its 
    rate and yield, and in general its efficiency and (2) the ability to predict 
    the precise stereochemistry and other subtle aspects of the structure of the 
    product. 
 
  
  - In our discussion of reaction mechanisms, we will designate 
    a general reactant or group of reactants as "R" and the product 
    of this general reaction as "P". 
 
  
  - Some reactions occur in a single elementary reaction 
    step. That is, all of the bonds which are to be broken in the reactant 
    and all of the bonds which are to be formed in the product are broken and 
    formed in one step. Such reactions are called "Concerted Reactions". 
     
 
 
  - Most reactions occur in two or more steps (possibly many). 
    Such reactions are called "Stepwise Reactions". In a stepwise 
    reaction, the formation of intermediates (to be defined) is involved. 
     
 
 
TRANSITION STATE THEORY
 
 
 
  - Consider a simple, one-step reaction. The reactant R is 
    converted to the product P by breaking one or more bonds of R and forming 
    one or more new bonds as found in P. The process of breaking bonds thus 
    requires energy, so nearly all reactions require some input of energy, 
    called activation energy. 
 
  
  - This can be illustrated by considering what we call a  
    Reaction Path Diagram, which plots the energy 
    (usually in uncalibrated units) on the vertical axis versus the Reaction 
    Coordinate, which is a measure of the progress of the reaction 
    from the geometry of R toward that of P. The point of highest energy on 
    this reaction path is called a Transition State. 
 
  
  - Formally, a transition state is defined as the state 
    of highest energy on the lowest energy reaction path. An important consequence 
    of this definition of the TS is that the energy difference between the 
    transition state (abbreviated as TS or as a double dagger) and that of the 
    reactant(s) is the activation energy. We will see 
    that this activation energy controls the rate of the reaction: the 
    lower the activation energy, the faster the reaction goes, and the higher 
    the activation energy, the slower the reaction goes. 
 
  
  - Various energy parameters can be used on the vertical axis. 
    We will start out by using the quantity G, the Gibbs free energy, because 
    rigorously this is the quantity which actually controls the rate. Other options 
    are the enthalpy H or the chemical energy,E, which are less directly related 
    to the rate. 
 
  
  - It is important to note that the (1)the energy difference 
    between the R and P controls the thermodynamic equilibrium between R and P 
    and that (2)the energy difference between the TS and R controls the rate 
    of the reaction. An important consequence of this is that the energy 
    of the product does not directly enter into the quantity (activation free 
    energy) which controls the rate of a reaction. However, the TS energy 
    obviously cannot be less than that of the P. 
 
  
  - In a two step reaction, illustrated in the second diagram 
    below,there is an intermediate state which, like the reactant and product, 
    is an energy minimum. This state is designated as I on the reaction path diagram 
    . The formal definition of an intermediate is an energy minimum encountered 
    on the reaction path between R and P . The physical significance of being 
    an intermediate, as opposed to a TS, is that a substance which exists at an 
    energy minimum has a significant lifetime and, in many cases, its presence 
    can be physically detected and its reactions chemically diverted if desired 
    to another course. A TS is so short lived that it cannot be detected by conventional 
    physical means, and its chemistry cannot be affected by any other reagent.
 
  
  -  In a two step reaction, there are two extreme scenarios, 
    i.e., either the first step is rate determining (we call such a step the rate 
    determining step or rds) or the second step is rate determining.(By extreme 
    we mean that possibly neither step will be rigorously rate determining). The 
    scenario illustrated below is one of the former type in which the first step 
    is rate determining. The concept of a rds is extremely important in dealing 
    with reaction rates of organic reactions. It is defined as a reaction step 
    the rate of which is equal to the overall rate of the reaction. 
    The importance of the concept is this: If the rate of a single step is exactly 
    equal to the overall rate of product formation (or of reactant consumption, 
    which should be the same thing), anything we know about the rate of this step 
    will immediately help us to know about the rate of the overall reaction. Thus, 
    if a reaction has 10 steps and one of them is rate determining, we really 
    don't need to know anything about the rate of 9 of them, if all we are interested 
    in is the rate of the overall reaction. Conversely, anything we learn about 
    the overall reaction rate immediately tells us about the rds and it alone. 
    
 
  
  - The reasons why the first step in the illlustrated diagram 
    is the rds are twofold: (1)Once the intermediate I is formed, it virtually 
    always goes on to product, as opposed to returning to the starting materials 
    (reactants). Why is this? Simply look at the height of the two barriers separating 
    I from P and from R. Note that the barrier for return to R is substantially 
    higher than that separating I from P. So the rate of return to R is much slower 
    than the rate of conversion to P. (2) The second requirement is that the 
    concentration of the intermediate must not build up, i.e., I is very quickly 
    converted to P, so that there is very little hold up. Thus, the overall picture 
    is that I essentially never returns to R and it doesn't buld up, but goes 
    quickly over to P .So, as fast as I is formed it is conerted to P. That makes 
    the rate of formation of I essentially equal (for all practical purposes, 
    equal) to the rate of formation of P. 
 
  
  - If the second step of the reaction is rate determining, 
    this corresponds to the first step being an equilibrium. That is the intermediate 
    rapidly goes back to R and only slowly on to P. In such a case, the activation 
    energy for the reaction is the energy difference between the transition state 
    of higher energy (in this case the second TS) and the R. See if you can 
    draw a reaction path diagram which proprerly shows that I goes back to R faster 
    than it goes on to P.  
 
 
REACTION PATH DIAGRAMS
 
 
 
 
Reaction Rates and Rate Constants
 
 Consider an elementary reaction step such as the one shown 
  below: 
 
 
 
 
  - The rate of the reaction is the rate at which P is formed 
    or R is consumed. This can normally be measured experimentally by simply 
    analyzing the amount of R present at various times. 
 
  
  - The rate is proportional to the concentration of R to the 
    first power, since the more R we have, the faster P is formed. 
 
  
  - The proportionality constant, designated as k (small 
    k, to distinguish it from the equilibrium constant K), is called the rate 
    constant. We should make a very clear distinction between the rate of a 
    reaction (the overall rate) and its rate constant. The rate constant 
    is a measure of the reaction rate at unit concentration of the reactant, 
    so that it is a measure of the inherent speed of the reaction, and is independent 
    of the concentration of the reagent. Any reaction can be speeded up by increasing 
    concentrations of reagents, but this doesn't affect the rate constant. 
 
  
  - It is this measure of the inherent rate of a reaction which 
    is related directly to the free energy of activation. The larger the activation 
    free energy required, the smaller the rate constant.  
 
 
  - Again, if a given step of a multistep reaction is the rds, 
    the rate of the overall reaction giving the final product is still equal to 
    the rate of this step. So the rate law for this single step gives the rate 
    law for the overall reaction. 
 
  
  - For any reaction, be it a single or multi-step reaction, 
    the expression which gives the overall rate of the reaction in terms of rate 
    constants and concentrations of reagents is called the Rate Law.  
 
 
 
An Example of a Reaction Mechanism: Addition 
  of HCl to An Alkene
 
CONSIDER THE ADDITION OF HCl 
  TO ISOBUTENE
 
 
 
IMPORTANT NOTES ABOUT THIS 
  MECHANISM
 
 
  - First, please note the format and conventions of writing 
    mechanisms. You must always write the different steps of a mechanism on 
    separate, numbered lines. 
 
  
  - You must always designate, if known, the rds. Also, if 
    any step is an equilibrium, this must be indicated by the use of equilibrium 
    arrows. 
 
  
  - You must show by means of arrows the flow of electrons 
    into the new bonds. In the first step, the electron pair of the pi bond 
    flows toward the hydrogen of HCl to form a carbon-hydrogen bond to one of 
    the alkene carbons, the other being left then with a positive charge (as a 
    carbocation). Since hydrogen cannot be divalent, the electron pair of the 
    H-Cl bond must flow onto the chlorine atom, generating a chloride anion. In 
    the second step, the electron pair on the chloride anion flows toward the 
    carbocation center to form a C-Cl bond. 
 
  
  - In this reaction, the overall result is the addition of 
    HCl to isobutene. The tert-butyl carbocation is an intermediate. Being 
    very reactive, it doesn't build up, but always goes on to the product. The 
    first step is the rds, while the second step is fast and not reversed. 
 
  
  - You should be able to explain why the first step is the 
    rds.This is really quite simple. The second step breaks no bonds and forms 
    a bond. It is therefore very favorable energetically ( it has a negative delta 
    G) and because no bonds are broken, it is very fast. However, in the first 
    step two bonds must be broken, and only one is formed. The breaking of two 
    bonds is in itself difficult, and in this case the reaction is also energetically 
    very uphill (unfavorable) because only one new bond is formed in the first 
    step. In general, with reasoning like this (simply noting how many bonds are 
    broken and formed), you can adequately rationalize or even predict which step 
    of a reaction will be the rds. 
 
  
  - Finally, please note that the carbocation intermediate is 
    very reactive because in it the carbocation center is only trivalent and it 
    can therefore readily form a new bond without breaking any bonds. It is 
    a strong Lewis acid. 
 
 
 
 A REACTION PATH DIAGRAM FOR 
  THIS REACTION
 
 
 
 
THINGS TO NOTE ABOUT THIS RP 
  DIAGRAM
 
 
  - Note that, overall in this reaction, two bonds are formed 
    (C-H and C-Cl) and two are broken (the C-C pi bond and the H-Cl bond), but 
    these are not all broken and formed at once. The lowest energy reaction path 
    involves breaking two of these bonds and forming one in the first step.
 
  
  - Again, note that an intermediate is an energy minimum. This 
    is the tert-butyl carbocation/chloride ion pair. Note that in the drawing, 
    the barrier to going on to the product (second step, via TS2) is smaller than 
    the barrier to going back to the reactant (via TS1). So the intermediate always 
    goes on to product , and the first step is rate determining. 
 
  
  - Note that the activation free energy is that of the first 
    step, since it is rate determining. No further activation is required, since 
    the intermediate always goes on to prodcuct, and never builds up in concentration. 
    
 
  
  - So, although there are two steps and two TS's, the second 
    one is of no consequence as far as the rate is concerned  
 
 
TRANSITION STATES AND TS MODELS
 
 
THE NATURE AND IMPORTANCE OF TRANSITION STATES
 
 
 
  - Transition states have extremely short lifetimes (less than 
    about 10 -13 seconds), so they are extremely difficult to detect. 
    We therefore have very little experimental knowledge about them. They exist 
    for so short a time (usually the time required for the vibration of a bond) 
    because they are at the top of the energy curve and require no further activation 
    to go on to product.  
 
 
  - Nevertheless, TS's are extrememly important, especially 
    in the context of reaction rates (they are irrelevant in the context of 
    equilibria; why?) because the energy of the TS relative to the reactant 
    determines the energy barrier, which in turn determines the rate of the reaction. 
    
 
  
  - Therefore, it is important that we have some information 
    about them, even qualitative information, in order to organize our knowledge 
    about the reaction and especially to be able to make some predictions about 
    relative rates.  
 
 
 
 
Transition State Models
 
 
  - For the above reasons,it is extremely valuable to have even 
    a rough and qualitative structural model of the transition state of a reaction, 
    such as the addition of HCl to isobutene. Such a model would contain information 
    about the magnitude and location of any charge which is generated in 
    the TS, an indication of any bonds which are being made or broken,and 
    other things. 
 
  
  - Resonance theory, 
    which we have discussed previously, provides a convenient way to derive a 
    TS model for any reaction. Since a TS is intermediate in geometry between 
    the reactant and product, it should be possible to represent it, using resonance 
    theory, as a resonance hybrid of reactant and product-like structures. 
    In fact, these should normally be the best two canonical structures. It may 
    be necessary, later,to provide additional structures also, but any transition 
    state should be a least reasonably well represented as a hybrid of these two 
    main structures.  
 
 
  - In applying resonance theory, it is important to recall 
    that all resonance structures apply to a common geometry, in this case, 
    that of the real TS, even though this may not be precisely known. The important 
    factor here is the two reactants in our case must be oriented at least 
    roughly as we anticipate them to be in the TS. In other words (see the 
    resonance structures below) with the H end of the H-Cl molecule approaching 
    a single carbon of the alkene double bond, since the proton is obviously going 
    to bond to one carbon. 
 
  
  - In the case of the first step of the reaction of H-Cl with 
    isobutene, which is the rds, the reactant-like (or R-like) structure is that 
    of isobutene and HCl, properly oriented. The product-like (or P-like) structure 
    is that of the tert-butyl carbocation/chloride ion pair, again properly 
    oriented. If we write the R-like structure properly oriented, we can generate 
    the P-like structure just by electron flow arrows, as shown. These electron 
    flow arrows should be shown when you are using TS theory to derive a TS model. 
     
 
  
  -  Dotted line/partial charge (DL/PC) Structures. This 
    completes the first step in deriving a TS model for our reaction step. We 
    can make this easier to analyze by summarizing the resonance theoretical treatment 
    in terms of a dotted line/partial charge (DL/PC) model. This is done 
    simply by representing any bonds which are being made or formed (i.e., any 
    bond which is made in the R and broken in P, or conversely) as dashed lines. 
    These dashed lines imply a Partial Bond. Secondly, partial charge accumulations 
    are represented by +d or -d 
    (lower case Greek delta) at the proper location. Any position which is 
    charged in one structure and not in the other has a partial charge. 
 
  
  - Our DL/PC model of the rds of the HCl/isobutene reaction 
    should now show the C-C pi bond as partial, as well as the H-Cl bond, both 
    of which are being broken. It should also show as partial the C-H bond which 
    is being formed. A partial positive charge is on the carbon which is not bonding 
    to the proton. We will call this the passive carbon since it is not 
    being attacked by the proton. 
 
  
  - We will see momentarily how this very simple TS model can 
    aid us in thinking about the results of organic reactions, not only reaction 
    rates but products of reactions. 
 
  
  - Finally, it wil be important for us to know how to think 
    with these TS models. What aspects or characteristics of the model are likely 
    to yield important insights into the reaction. We call this "Characterizing 
    the TS". In this case, the main character of importance in the TS 
    is THE DEVELOPMENT OF CARBOCATION CHARACTER AT THE PASSIVE 
    CARBON. Note that the character and its location are both specified. 
    Later, we will learn to further refine and extend  this TS character. 
     
 
 
 
RESONANCE THEORETICAL TREATMENT 
  OF A TS
 
 
 
 
REGIOSPECIFICITY AND TS MODELS
 
 
 
  - Regiospecificity: Let's 
    begin immediately to put the TS model and its character to use. We can do 
    this by considering the regiochemistry of the HCl addition reaction. 
    Note (see illustration) that there are two senses in which HCl could potentially 
    add to isobutene, one which gives the product actually observed, tert-butyl 
    chloride and one which would have led to isobutyl chloride. Essentially,this 
    corresponds to a very high degree of selectivity for the proton adding to 
    the CH2 end of the alkene and the Cl adding to the other end, as 
    opposed to the opposite situation. This orientational selectivity is called 
    "regioselectivity" or "regiospecificity" 
    (organic chemists can't seem to make up their minds about this) . Of course, 
    this does not even come up in the case of a symmetrically substituted alkene 
    like ethene, or even with isobutene when it reacts with a symmetrical reagent 
    like Cl2. It only comes into play when two unsymmetrical reagents 
    react.  
 
  
  - Method of Competing Transition States: Let's 
    now attempt to represent a TS model for each of these two reactions. Since 
    we have already developed the model for the observed isobutene reaction, we 
    don't have to go all the way back and do the same thing for the other regiochemical 
    sense. All we have to do is turn the isobutene around so that the proton is 
    bonding to the more hindered end of the alkene (illustration).The TS models 
    are very similar, except that the carbocation character is being developed 
    in one case at a tertiary carbon and in the other case at a primary carbon. 
    We will thus refine our TS characterization to read "tertiary carbocation 
    character at the passive carbon" in one case, and " primary 
    carbocation character at the passive carbon' in the other.  
 
  
  - In a short while , we will learn that tertiary carbocations 
    are much more stable than primary carbocations(and why). Thus, the TS 
    with tertiary carbocation caharacter is much more favorable (lower in energy) 
    than the TS with primary carbocation character. We can thus see why the reaction 
    proceeding via the tertiary TS is much faster, and why the tert-butyl 
    chloride product is essentially the only one observed.  
 
, 
 
TS MODELS RATIONALIZE THE OBSERVED 
  REGIOCHEMISTRY
 
 
 
  - The general procedure we will use for such comparisons is 
    the METHOD OF COMPETING TRANSITION STATES. 
    We, of course, use TS Models of the TS's of the competing reactions. The lower 
    the energy of a series of competing transition states, the lower the activation 
    energy, and the faster the reaction. The reaction which will be preferred 
    is the faster one, of course.  
 
 
  -  In the diagram above,the TS which has tertiary carbocation 
    character is of lower energy than that which has primary carbocation 
    character, because positive charge on a tertiary carbon is more stable than 
    ion a secondary or primary carbon. The lower the energy of the TS, the lower 
    the activation energy and the faster the reaction. Thus protonation of the 
    methylene carbon is faster than protonation of the carbon bearing two methyl 
    groups. [Incidentally, there is also a steric factor which favors the approach 
    to the less sterically hindered methylene carbon]
 
  
  - In general, the development of tertiary carbocation 
    character in a TS is more favorable than secondary carbocation character, 
    which is more favorable than primary carbocation character. The least 
    favorable is methyl carbocation character.  
 
  
  - The product of the reaction of HCl with isobutene is thus 
    tert-butyl chloride (i.e., 2-chloro-2-methylpropane) and essentially 
    no isobutyl chloride (i.e., 1-chloro-2-methylpropane) is formed. In the case 
    of addition to propene, isopropyl chloride is formed, and no substantial amount 
    of 1-chloropropane (secondary vs. primary carbocation character in this case). 
    The regiochemistry of addition is predicted by a qualitative rule, called 
    the MARKOVNIKOV RULE: : "In electrophilic additions of HX, the 
    proton adds to the less highly substituted carbon atom of the 
    double bond". We can now understand , and we should be able to explain, 
    that this is a result of the development of positive charge on the more highly 
    substituted carbon atom, where the charge is more highly stabilized. (Recall 
    that carbocation character is developed not on the carbon being attacked by 
    the proton, but on the "passive carbon".  
 
  
  - Two other additional examples are provided in the diagram 
    below.You should be able to predict the orientation of the addition of 
    HCl to virtually any alkene using (1)the Markovnikov Rule and (2)rationalize 
    it bY drawing competing transition states for the two modes of addition. 
     
 
 
 
RELATIVE RATES OF HCl ADDITION
 
 
RELATIVE RATES OF ADDITION 
  TO DIFFERENT ALKENES
 
 
 
  - The relative rates of addition of HCl to different alkenes 
    can also be predicted using the same Method of Competing TS's. This 
    is important tool, because the rates of addition to some alkenes may be slow, 
    to others modest, and to others fast. The alkenes which react very slowly 
    may need to be reacted at a higher temperature in order to obtain a reasonable 
    reaction rate. We need to know which alkene we are dealing with and whether 
    to expect its reaction to be fast or slow. This can be especially important 
    when two or more alkene functions are present in the same molecule. We 
    could then predict which one of them will react fastest, and may be able to 
    leave the less reactive one intact.  
 
  
  - In the reaction series isobutene, propene, and ethene(shown 
    above) the first named alkene reacts very fast, while the last one reacts 
    relatively slowly. Propene reacts at an intermediate rate. Such a sequence 
    of relative rates can be easily predicted or explained, by observing that 
    the TS's for the additions have tertiary, secondary, and primary carbocation 
    character, respectively. 
 
  
  - It is important to note, as is also shown in the above diagram, 
    that a disubstituted alkene having both alkyl groups attached to the same 
    carbon, such as isobutene, reacts much more rapidly than a disubstituted alkene 
    having one alkyl group on each carbon, such as 2-butene, because positive 
    charge is developed upon only one of the alkene carbon atoms. Thus, the 
    TS for addition to 2-butene has only secondary carbocation character, the 
    second alkyl group not being at a site of positive charge and exerting little 
    effect upon the reaction rate.  
 
 
 
CARBOCATIONS
 
 
 
  
  -  The important new point to be added here is that carbocations, 
    though extremely reactive as a class, vary greatly in their stability and 
    reactivity. In particular,the stability order is tertiary>secondary>primary>methyl. 
    The reactivity order is just the reverse. That is, the methyl carbocation 
    is the least stable and the most reactive. The classification of primary, 
    secondary, etc. is made on the basis of whether the trigonal, carbocation 
    center has 1,2, or 3 carbons bonded to it. 
 
  
  - The replacement of each hydrogen on the methyl carbocation 
    by an alkyl group furnishes an increment of additional stabilization. We say 
    that alkyl groups stabilize a carbocation center.
 
  
  - The amount of stabilization per alkyl group is approximately 
    15-20 kcal/mol even in the solution phase. It is much greater than this 
    in the gas phase. The amount of the stabilization is thus relatively large, 
    either in solution or in the gas phase. 
 
  
  - The stabilization of a carbocation center by an alkyl group 
    occurs by two distinct means: (1) a resonance effect, specifically, 
    hyperconjugation and (2) an inductive effect. 
 
  
  -  Hyperconjugation. You recall 
    that a resonance effect refers to situations in which a single structure does 
    not adequately represent the bonding and charge distribution in a molecule. 
    The electrons are thus more highly delocalized than in any single canonical 
    structure. A hyperconjugative effect is a specific type of resonance effect 
    in which the delocalization involves a sigma bond. Referring to the resonance 
    structures for the ethyl carbocation, shown below, structure B is also a valid 
    structure which has the same number of bonds as that of A (although they are 
    of different types). Notice that B shows that the positive charge is not localized 
    completely upon the central carbon atom, but is delocalized onto the hydrogens 
    which are beta to the carbocation center. To put it differently, the electrons 
    in the C-H sigma bonds are delocalized onto the carbocation site, forming 
    a partial pi bond between the carbocation site and the attached carbon atoms. 
    The real structure of the ethyl carbocation is thus a resonance hybrid 
    of these two structures and is intermediate between the two. However, 
    since structure A is of lower energy than B, the real structure more closely 
    resembles A than B. Thus, there is more charge on carbon 
    than on H, and the carbocation tends to react more readily at carbon than 
    at H. Note that A is of lower energy than B because a relatively strong 
    C-H bond in A is replaced by a much weaker C-C pi bond in B.  
 
  
  - The overlap which gives rise to the resonance stabilization/delocalization 
    is between the 2p orbital on the carbocation center and the sp3 
    orbital on the beta carbon. If there is no beta carbon, as in the methyl carbocation, 
    this critical overlap is missing.
 
  
  - Each additional alkyl group attached to the carbocation 
    center provides additional delocalization, so that the isopropyl carbocation(which 
    has two alkyl groups) is more stable than the ethyl carbocation(which has 
    just one) and the tertiary butyl carbocation(which has the maximum of three) 
    is more stable than either. Please note that the methyl carbocation has no 
    beta hydrogens to delocalize the charge. Alpha hydrogens can't delocalize 
    the charge, which you can verify by attempting to write good resonance structures 
    for the methyl carbocation (there are none). 
 
  
  - The inductive effect which stabilizes a carbocation 
    center results from the induction of a bond diple in the C-C and the C-H bonds 
    by the carbocation center. The positive charge on this carbon makes it very 
    electron deficient, so that it behaves like a very highly electronegative 
    atom and this makes the C-C bond very polar covalent bond, with the negative 
    end at the carobocation center. This partial negative charge is attracted 
    to and stabilizes the positive charge of the carbocation center(the negative 
    potential energy of attraction of opposite charges). Similarly, the positive 
    charge on the beta carbon, makes it somewhat more electronegative than is 
    usual for carbon, and it induces dipoles in the C-H bonds which are oriented 
    with the negative end of the dipole closer to the carbocation center, resulting 
    in a net stabilization. So the inductive effect here refers to the induction 
    of bond dipoles in the neighboring bonds.  
 
 
 
REFINING THE TS MODEL: THE 
  HAMMOND PRINCIPLE
 
 
 
  - Finally, it is important, in the consideration of TS models, 
    not only to be able to discern the qualitative character of the TS, but also 
    to have some idea of the extent to which this character is developed 
    in the TS.For example, in the purely hypothetical case that the addition of 
    HCl to an alkene had only a very minor amount of carbocation character upon 
    the passive carbon, the rates of reaction of isobutene, propene, and ethene 
    might not be very different at all. Further, the rates of protonation of the 
    two non-equivalent carbons of isobutene might not be very different, so that 
    both product regioisomers would be produced in significant amounts. The reaction 
    would thus be said to be relatively "unselective". If, 
    however, there is very extensive development of carbocation character, so 
    that the TS closely resembles a carbocation, we can expect that the reaction 
    will be very selective. Rate differences between various alkenes will 
    therefore be very large, and the regiospecificity of addition to an unsymmetrical 
    alkene will also be high.  
 
 
  - The Hammond Principle prodvides an excellent approach 
    to further refining our TS as to the extent of a given character developed 
    in a TS. Essentially, the postulate states that "The 
    TS of a given reaction step more closely resembles the reaction partner (reactant 
    or product) of highest energy." Thus, if a reaction is highly 
    endothermic (or endergonic), the TS tends to more closely resemble 
    the product than the reactant, although it is still a resonance hybride 
    of both. If, on the other hand, a reaction is highly exothermic (or exergonic), 
    the TS tends to more closely resemble the reactant. Traditionally, 
    the Hammond Principle is discussed in terms of enthalpies, that is, endothermicity 
    and exothermicity.
 
  
  - It is important to note that the Hammond Principle helps 
    define the TS for a specific, single reaction step, not the overall reaction. 
    Since we are considering relative rates, the step we are most interested in 
    is the rds, becasuse the rate of the reaction equals the rate of this step. 
    In the addition of HCl to an alkene, this step is quite endothermic. We could, 
    and would be expected to, simply look at this reaction step and predict that 
    it would be endothermic. Remember that two bonds are broken in this reaction 
    and only one formed. It is thus substantially endothermic. As a matter of 
    convenience, it may be well to remember that any time a high energy intermediate 
    such as a carbocation is formed, that reaction step is endothermic.  
    From the Hammond Principle we may then conclude that the 
    TS for this step closely resembles the product (of that 
    step), which is a carbocation. Therefore the TS for the rds of 
    this reaction has very extensive carbocation character. 
     
 
 
  - On the other hand, the final step (which is fast and 
    not rate determining) is highly exothermic, so the TS for that step (reaction 
    of a carbocation with the chloride anion) closely resembles the reactant. 
    By the way, the reactant in this step is also this same carbocation. Therefore 
    the TS for both steps closely resembles the carbocation. 
    Nevertheless, we are presently interested only in the rds (because we are 
    concerned with relative rates).  
 
  
  - Consequently, we can predict that rate 
    ratios in the series of alkenes previously considered will be large, and also 
    regiospecificity in the addition to an unsymmetrical alkene will be high, 
    as indeed is the case.  
 
 BACK TO THE TOP OF THIS PAGE  
 BACK TO ALKENES 1 
 ON TO THE FINAL PART OF ALKENES 
  
 BACK TO THE BAULD HOME PAGE